Charles Clanton Rogers

Reflections based on poetry, music, visual art, book reviews, history of science, first-person history, philosophical essays and International Blogging


In our culture, we yearn for heroes. The Ancient Greeks invented some for us. Our heroes have been the protagonists of our fictional literature (and oral legend) from before recorded history.  We insist that some people who were undoubtably real people be elevated to heroic stature depending on the needs of our story line. Example include Joan d’Arc, George Washington and Abraham Lincoln.  Don’t tell us they were’t perfect; we require the ideal. We need them as templates with which to judge the ethics of our own decisions and actions. Survey children’s and young adult’s literature, heroes abound. Our idol faces down a rigorous challenge, then, like Wesley in The Princess Bride,   he saves that which we cherish (Buttercup) from Evil! (1)  In Mockingbird, Atticus Finch fails to save the accused but with great bravery he stands tall and challenges the cruel bigotry of his community. While defending the highest ideals of Justice, he teaches his daughter responsible citizenship.

“Say it ain’t so, Joe!”  

In 1919, Shoeless Joe Jackson and the Chicago White Sox found themselves back in the running for another World Series ring. Jackson batted .351 during the regular season and .375 with perfect fielding in the World Series. The heavily favored Sox found themselves in a losing battle against the Cincinnati Reds. During the next year while batting .385 and leading the American league in triples.  Jackson was suspended after allegations that eight members of the White Sox threw the previous World Series.  (2)

In an 1988 Motion Picture, Eight Men Out, there is an iconic scene where, in the wake of the scandal, a distraught boy confronts Shoeless Joe, pleading: “Say it ain’t so Joe!” (3)

July 11, there was a post on-line, from PBS, citing Harper Lee’s prequel: Go Set a Watchman.(4) A spoiler alert says that this publication of Lee’s first book attempt (set at a later time than the “Mockingbird”  setting (5), describes Atticus Finch as having racial views. (6)

I wrote a comment to that post: “I want Atticus Finch to stay in ‘Mockingbird’ only”.   When I last checked, my comments had received fifty-two “likes” which is afairly strong agreement.

One dissenting critic chastised me for my comment, pointing out that a fictional character belonged to the author and not to the reader. My response to that is:

Go Set a Watchman was Lee’s draft of her attempt of a first book which was rejected for publication and was purposely left unpublished for half a century while Harper Lee cherished her privacy. With recommendations  and encouragement, Lee set her (only) novel, (a complete and instant classic, by-the-way), in an earlier time when her characters were much younger.  In this second attempt, Lee defined exactly the right characterizations required of the drama she was penning. The “Mockingbird message” is a lessor work without Atticus Finch as portrayed by Gregory Peck.      .

Secondly, Atticus Finch is not a real person. I’m not legally liable for my interpretation and description, so lay off.  I’m free to fantasize and identify with Superman and Mr. Smith (7) as my psyche requires.   I will have my heroes:  a’ la carte, Thank you, very much.

In my humble opinion, the publishers should have left Go Set a Watchman, unpublished in a safety deposit box. Harper Lee already was an American Icon.

(1( The Princess Bride, The Motion Picture, 1987

(2) Joe Jackson Official Website. (In 1921 A Chicago jury acquitted Jackson of helping to fix the 1919 World Series, but Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the first commissioner of Baseball went against the ruling and banned all eight players including Joe Jackson from baseball for life.)

(3) Eight Men Out, The Motion Picture,

(4) Harper Lee, Go Set a Watch Man,  Harper 2015

(5) Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird, J P Lipincott, 1960

(6) Go Set a Watchman, PBS, July 11, 2015

(7) Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, Motion Picture, 1939

4 thoughts on ““Say It Ain’t So, Atticus!”

  1. Agree with you, although it’s pretty timely that the beloved Atticus Finch returns as a character at a time when overt and covert racism is (necessarily) at the forefront of conversation.

    It’s also interesting, as I read in a NYT article about the editor who guided Harper Lee through an extensive


    1. process of reworking “Go Set a Watchman” into “To Kill A Mockingbird” that the young author needed a heavy hand to turn her stories into publishable prose. Unfortunately this newest release didn’t get that kind of editorial guidance.


      1. clanton1934 says:

        Thanks for the NYT reference. That is a most remarkable insight as to the development of TKAM.
        Even more reason why Watchman should have stayed in the vault. Harper Lee’s iconic status will be compromised.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Food for Poetryy

eat, sip, travel, click, pen down poetry = Helps best reflect on life !

The Wine Wankers

G’day, you’re at the best wine blog ever! We're all about wine; without the wankery.

Faraday's Candle

It's an amazing world of science...let's go exploring!


(旧・しまやん香港アジア支局) 人生は旅のすべて、日々を綴っていきます。

L.T. Garvin

Eclectic blog: short fiction, poetry, humor, occasional dreams and wild book schemes.


hand knits + patterns inspired by nature

Exploring the history of prisoner health

Prisoners, Medical Care and Entitlement to Health in England and Ireland, 1850-2000

Life Is Fiction

~ David Ben-Ami ~

Logical Quotes

Logical and Inspirational quotes

A Narcissist Writes Letters, To Himself

A Hopefully Formerly Depressed Human Vows To Practice Self-Approval

Leonard Durso

"Literature is language charged with meaning." Ezra Pound

%d bloggers like this: